critique a new logo

[grumpy]

I'm having a logo designed for one of my web sites, www.anythingcedar.com

Take a peek at the site and see the very rough layout, then give me your input on these logos.
http://anythingcedar.com/temp/anythingcedar.jpg

[Cole]

1 or 2 for me, 1 jumps out at you with the colors.

[Rich]

I like #2

[grumpy]

Personally I don't think the trees look like cedar trees. Also I like #3 myself.

[Rich]

Looks a lot like a cedar tree..
http://phoenicia.org/imgs/cedar2.jpg

[Cole]

Hell Grumpy I like all of them!!!

[grumpy]

Yeah I guess it does. I did a search on Yahoo Images and I see a few species of trees. One of them is that, others look more like pine.

I'm still contimplating. #1 stood out for me but the colors don't quite fit. #3 is my favorite so far.

[ITE]

Grumpy,

I personally like #4 the best. The lines and curves are sleek and smooth, appealing to the eye and seem professional. Green is supposed to be the new in color so Im told. just my 2 cents.

[Tom R]

I like #4 the best, too, - - kind of puts you in a 'comfort zone'.

[Cole]

I have to change my mind now, #4 looks the most professional.

[grumpy]

LOL this post is still alive?

People it's dead. Stop posting.

[Cole]

lol

[Tom McNall]

4 looks good

[wayne]

1 or 2 I would say